Third-Party Lawsuits in Work Injury Cases: Beyond Workers’ Comp

An injured worker at a construction site reviewing paperwork, illustrating a third-party lawsuit alongside workers' comp.
Alexander Shunnarah Trial Attorneys


Alexander Shunnarah Trial Attorneys


Did you know workers’ comp isn’t always your only option after a job injury? If someone not your employer caused it, you may be able to file a third-party lawsuit. You might be able to collect workers’ compensation at the same time.

Defining a Third-Party Lawsuit in a Workers’ Compensation Case

Most injured workers know about workers’ compensation. Fewer know they may have a second claim.

Workers’ compensation is a trade-off. You get medical care and part of your lost wages, no matter who was at fault. In return, you usually cannot sue your employer for the injury. This “exclusive remedy rule” only protects your employer, not a third party.

Example: Alabama

Under Ala. Code § 25-5-11, you can file a third-party lawsuit and still collect workers’ comp. Our guide on workers’ compensation vs. personal injury claims explains how the two categories compare.

Who is Eligible to be a Third-Party

A third party is anyone who helped cause your injury, but they’re not your employer. At Alexander Shunnarah Trial Attorneys, we’ve helped thousands of employees like you. We’ve built cases against negligent third parties, including drivers and manufacturers.

A Negligent Driver

If you drive for work and another driver hits you, then that person is a third party. You can pursue their insurance plus your comp benefits.

An Equipment Maker

If a defective machine, tool, or piece of safety gear hurt you, the company that made it may be liable. A faulty respirator or a machine with no guard are common examples.

A Subcontractor or Another Company

Job sites often have workers from many companies. If a subcontractor’s crew caused the accident, that company may owe you, even though it is not your employer.

A Property Owner

If an unsafe condition on someone else’s property hurt you, the owner may be responsible.

Determining who counts as a third party requires studying the facts. The best thing you can do is talk to a workers’ compensation attorney.

Why You Should File a Third-Party Claim on Top of Workers’ Comp

Workers’ comp helps, but it does not cover everything. A third-party claim can fill the gaps.

Workers’ comp pays your medical bills and part of your lost wages. But it does not pay for pain and suffering. Plus, it only covers a portion of your lost wages. For a serious injury, that shortfall can be huge.

Unlike comp, a third-party lawsuit can recover full lost wages, pain and suffering, and more. This matters most in severe cases. Think of a worker left with a chemical burn from a defective product. Our guide on chemical burns at work shows how a third-party claim can apply.

Basically, workers’ compensation covers the basics, no matter who was at fault. A third-party claim fights for everything that the comp leaves out.

Frequently Asked Questions About Third-Party Work Injury Claims

What is a third-party lawsuit in a workers’ comp case?

A third-party lawsuit in a workers’ comp case is a claim against someone other than your employer who caused your work injury. Workers’ comp is usually your only claim against your employer. But you can sue an at-fault third party, like a negligent driver or equipment maker.

Can I file a third-party lawsuit and get workers’ compensation at the same time?

Yes, if someone other than your employer caused your injury. Then, you can file a third-party lawsuit and get workers’ compensation at the same time. Workers’ comp covers your basic losses no matter who was at fault. The third-party claim pursues the at-fault party for damages that comp doesn’t pay, like pain and suffering.

Who can I sue as a third party after a work injury?

You may be able to sue a third party. Examples include a negligent driver, the maker of defective equipment, a subcontractor, or a property owner. The key is that the party is not your employer and their carelessness helped cause your injury.

Does a third-party claim pay more than workers’ comp?

Yes, it can. Workers’ comp pays medical bills and part of your lost wages, but not pain and suffering. A third-party claim can recover full lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages. For a serious injury, a third-party lawsuit often provides much more than comp alone, which is why pursuing both can matter so much.

Will I have to pay back my workers’ comp?

It depends. If you win a third-party lawsuit, your workers’ comp insurer has a right to be repaid through subrogation. The insurer generally must share in your legal fees. However, an attorney can negotiate the amount down.

Trust Alexander Shunnarah Trial Attorneys Today

After you’re hurt, workers’ compensation is a start, but it’s rarely the whole story. If a third party hurt you, you may be owed more. Our attorneys are dedicated to handling both claims to fight for your recovery. Schedule a free case review today.

Reviewed by Alexander Shunnarah, Attorney and Chief Executive Officer at Alexander Shunnarah Trial Attorneys, on 2026-09-29.

Bio: https://shunnarah.com/attorney/alexander-shunnarah/

Related Articles

A calendar is in a planner to illustrate the kind of timeline an Alabama wrongful death statute of limitations case demands.

Alabama Wrongful Death Statute of Limitations: How Long Do You Have?

The photo is a close-up of a tire after exploding on the interstate, illustrating the situation where someone may need a Birmingham wrongful death attorney for a defective product.

Birmingham Wrongful Death Attorneys and Defective Product Cases

A woman uses talcum powder on her hands, illustrating the concept of a talcum powder lawsuit.

Talcum Powder Lawsuit Update: Ovarian Cancer and Mesothelioma Claims

A swaddled newborn sleeps at the side of its mother’s hospital bed, illustrating the potential aftermath of shoulder dystocia.

What Is Shoulder Dystocia? Causes, Risks, and When It Becomes Malpractice

The photo shows Alexander Shunnarah at the firm's 2025 turkey drive.

Alexander Shunnarah Hosts Fifth Annual Turkey Drive

A small general aviation aircraft on a runway at sunrise, illustrating the scenario where someone may need an aviation lawyer.

Aviation Lawyers: How Aviation Cases Differ

A caretaker crouches next to a woman in a wheelchair, illustrating the concept of choosing between assisted living and a nursing home.

Assisted Living vs. Nursing Home: Key Differences

A young woman uses a wheelchair to cross a road, illustrating the concept of paraplegic vs quadriplegic.

Paraplegic vs. Quadriplegic: What the Difference Means for Your Case

A Black man steps out of the passenger side of a vehicle, rubbing his neck. This photo illustrates the question of who to sue if you’re a passenger in a car accident.

Injured as a Passenger in a Car Accident: Who Do You Sue?

A doctor shows a medical diagram to a patient, illustrating the concept of a hernia mesh lawsuit.

Hernia Mesh Lawsuit Update: Who Qualifies and What to Expect

A medical professional carefully studies the patient’s burn, illustrating that the patient may need a burn injury attorney.

Burn Injury Attorneys Explain What to Do After Being Hurt

A rideshare accident is viewed through a side mirror, illustrating the type of scene where a Birmingham rideshare accident attorney would be helpful.

Birmingham Rideshare Accident Lawyer: Evidence That Matters